  "Microwave Madness" Page - 63 | Quest | Common | – |
 Midge Poison | Quest | Common | – |
 Mindplague Essence | Quest | Common | – |
 Mine Cart Parts | Quest | Common | – |
 Missing Note | Quest | Common | – |
 Missing Pages | Quest | Common | – |
 Missing Persons Poster | Quest | Common | – |
 Mobius Mask | Quest | Common | – |
 Mocha Caramel Latte | Quest | Common | – |
 Morick's Evidence Jar | Quest | Common | – |
 Morick's Evidence Jar | Quest | Common | – |
 Morick's Evidence Jar | Quest | Common | – |
 Mortimer Gloomsworth Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Mr. Fuzzywuzzy | Quest | Common | – |
 Mudroot Tuber | Quest | Common | – |
 Mysterious Bottle | Quest | Common | – |
 Mysterious Green Mask | Quest | Common | – |
 Mysterious Luchador Mask | Quest | Common | – |
 Mysterious Orange Mask | Quest | Common | – |
 Mysterious Pink Mask | Quest | Common | – |
| Newcomer blank | Quest | Common | – |
 Newcomer Form | Quest | Uncommon | – |
 Nia's Nunya Beeswax | Quest | Common | – |
| Nia’s Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Notary Hint | Quest | Common | – |
 Notary Stamp | Quest | Common | – |
 Note Cause of Death | Quest | Common | – |
 Note of Evidence | Quest | Common | – |
| Note Time of Death | Quest | Common | – |
 Noxious spore | Quest | Common | – |
 Oasis Flower | Quest | Common | – |
 Odd Plant | Quest | Common | – |
 Odd Sketch | Quest | Common | – |
 Oil Lamp | Quest | Common | – |
| Ol' Fin's Note | Quest | Common | – |
 Omen Page | Quest | Common | – |
 Orange Horns Mask | Quest | Common | – |
| Ore Extractor | Quest | Common | – |
| Oswald Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Oswald's Black Book | Quest | Common | – |
 Oswald's Souvenir Sword | Quest | Common | – |
 Ovenheim Ring | Quest | Common | – |
| Ovenheim Ring | Quest | – | 200 |
 Oxidized battery | Quest | Common | – |
| Paddy O'Lantern Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Page 1: Plague - Frogs | Quest | Common | – |
| Page 1: Plague - Frogs | Quest | – | 200 |
 Page 2: War - Bear | Quest | – | 200 |
| Page 2: War - Bear | Quest | Common | – |
 Page 3: Hunger - Wolf | Quest | Common | – |