 Overdrive Annihilator | Advanced Chip | – | 125,000 |
 Overload Loop | Artifact | – | 135,000 |
 Overwhelming Rage | Rune | – | 140,000 |
  Oxidized battery | Quest | Common | – |
 Oxygenating | Advanced Chip | – | 7,500 |
  Pacesetter's Chest | Alchemy | Uncommon | – |
 Paddy O'Lantern Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Page 1: Plague - Frogs | Quest | Common | – |
| Page 1: Plague - Frogs | Quest | – | 200 |
 Page 2: War - Bear | Quest | – | 200 |
| Page 2: War - Bear | Quest | Common | – |
 Page 3: Hunger - Wolf | Quest | Common | – |
| Page 3: Hunger - Wolf | Quest | – | 200 |
 Page 4: Death - Raven | Quest | Common | – |
| Page 4: Death - Raven | Quest | – | 200 |
 Paint Bucket | Quest | Common | – |
 Pallid Tongues | Quest | Common | – |
 Pants | Quest | Common | – |
 Pappy Rick's Portal Juice | Quest | Common | – |
 Paramedic Bracer | Artifact | – | 20,000 |
 Pasta "Bloodonjeze" | Dishes | – | 6,656 |
 Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
| Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
| Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
| Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
| Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
| Patched Gent's Topper | Skin | – | 3,000 |
 Pearl Of The Sea | Quest | Common | – |
| Percival "Percy" Beamish Thank You Letter | Quest | Common | – |
 Petrified Mana Talisman | Artifact | – | 20,000 |
  Petrified Spike | Herbalism | Rare | 5,000 |
 Petrol | Quest | Uncommon | – |
 Petroleum | Quest | Common | – |
| Photographs | Searchable | Common | 300 |
 Photon Aegis | Weapon | – | 675,000 |
 Photon Spear | Weapon | – | 675,000 |
 Piece of Strudel | Quest | Common | – |
 Piece of Watermelon | Food | – | 352 |
 Piece pumpkin | Food | – | 956 |
 Pieces of Evidence | Quest | Common | – |
 Pig | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pig Adventurer | Skin | – | 20,000 |
 Pinecast Cone | Generic | Common | 125 |
 Pinecone Fish Stew | Dishes | – | 1,208 |
 Pink Radioactive Hoverboard | Skin | – | 20,000 |